Entry tags:
Four Walls of Text Do Not A Home Make
At this moment, I’m thinking about work. Not just my work, but that too. My work is pleasing to me, I feel like I am of value to the organization and I have a certain amount of pride invested in the organization so that its fortunes are something I care for whether they impact my ‘fortunes’ or not, only because I want to participate in victorious enterprises. Who doesn’t right? Still, my work doesn’t pay me as much as I’d like and there are things that I want for, foolish unneeded things no doubt, but I am flawed and thus want.
But I’ve been thinking more about work as a principle, a phenomenon.
Say you’re a bushman, you’ll work, sometimes. You’ll hunt and gather and endure strange privations and make unconscionable choices, you’ll be a bushman. You’ll exert effort. An observer could say that you are working - because it’s by the expense of calories in sweat and thought that you persist.
Say you’re a businessman, you’ll work. You’ll strategize and plan and though you’ll endure not too many privations, you’ll make unconscionable choices, you’ll be a businessman. You’ll exert effort. An observer couldn’t say exactly what you are working on – because it’s by the accumulation of unused calories that you are dying prematurely.
Say you’re a workingman, you’ll work. You’ll follow a pattern, obey regulations and you’ll endure strange privations, you’ll make no choices, you’ll be a workingman. You’ll exert an effort. An observer could say you were working because you pursued tasks singlemindedly for a scheduled interval and you were compensated in turn – and it’s by these accumulated hours that you’ll pay your rent.
Say you’re a thinking man, you’ll work. You’ll wonder why you have to work, exactly, you’ll be satisfied to get the steady work when it’s available, but you’ll think a bit, not obsessively mind, but still, you’ll think in your solitary moments about what it means that you’re working. You’ll think of the bushman and the businessman and the workingman – you’ll place yourself somewhere in a venn diagram that describes them all. You’ll be familiar with Marx, you’ll have some sense of your own value and consider why and how you parcel out the surplus. You might develop strange cares and exotic needs and thus you’ll work, though your heart’s not in it, your heart’s in thinking, you’re a thinking man and so you’ve a sense of Smith and how capital accumulates. You’ll look at your increasingly sophisticated computer and cleverer and cleverer tools and realize that it’s only a matter of time before you’re marked as an expense that can’t be justified by a businessman. You might have some nostalgia, misplaced or no, for the heyday of the workingman – having come from such people, you cast around and wonder where they’ve all gone. You’ll take the work you can get until you can’t and then you’ll have to catch as catch can and maybe go be the urban sphere’s version of a bushman. Maybe you’ll hunt opportunities, or suckers or victims, maybe you’ll gather cans or copper or unemployment. A shrewd observer can tell you’re working, you’re doing something and it’s somehow helping you to keep on living, it’s keeping you indoors anyway and heck – winter is coming. Winter is always coming and the wolves are always near the door.
It’s not that laziness is rewarded, it rarely is and idleness, whether a virtue or a vice, is its own reward – these aren’t the points to be made here, not the ideas this is meant to address. Put aside your suspicions about the people in the office next door and the good life that they may or may not be getting without working as hard or harder than you. Let’s think instead about working, but more to the point, about jobs.
Work, you do, like a machine – whether you get paid or not, it’s work just thinking, just sitting, just existing, there’s exertion. What I mean to speak about is the job. More to the point, I mean to speak about the weird serfdom that’s so commonplace as to be an assumption rather than a wonder. I follow my congressional delegation and local politicians through the various social media channels that they use to get their points across and their points are often, curiously focused on the matter of jobs. “Training! A local victory! A factory retained! Jobs kept!” There’s a lot of variation on this particular theme and I have learned something in my observance of politics and it is this: Whenever the parties that amount to the American leadership are in complete agreement on a matter – that matter is the rotten core that pollutes the otherwise good world. Save the financial system! (though most people might be net-debtors and beholden to it rather than served by it) – Conquer the fertile crescent! (though the expense in righteousness won’t be justified by the gains of the already morally suspect, though the results might be unconscionable and utterly ruinous, though such conquest might undermine the whole of society and tip us all into darkness) – Provide and sustain jobs! (though the tasks we set people to might be without merit and their spirits might be crushed by the weight of colossal misanthropy of the world of commerce). Really, it’s rather worth noticing when members of the different parties are in lockstep because this circumstance naturally indicates that their constituent members are being swindled the most thoroughly.
So Sherrod Brown and Mike Kasich and Rob Portman all tweet to me that they are attempting to retain or keep jobs – this in between their various anecdotal, almost human interactions with their environment, I am told about sports victories and classic car enthusiasm and wedged in between these hokey slices of almost plausible Americana is the tattletale insistence that jobs are the matter of utmost significance. Arbeit – it seems – Macht Frei.
Sure I was raised in an ostensibly protestant household and made to consider that famous ethic of work as a sacrosanct demonstration of True Character – punching the clock, showing up early, staying late, seeing it through till Friday and showing up, ready to work come Monday, the latter-day sacraments of a faith with precious few sacraments. Arbeit – I was raised to believe – Macht Heilig.
Which is an uncanny sort of nonsense. Work is fine, the Bushman works, the businessman works – everyone works, the ant and the grasshopper, each in their turn and season – but of these – which has a job. Sure, sure – it’s right and proper that idle hands be turned to useful labor and it’s right and proper that useful labor be compensated. Not fairly, mind, but according rather to the ebbs and flows of market forces, and cursed be he who seeks to unfairly tamper with that marketplace! No-no, you live and die by your competitive merits, and never, even ever, think to rig the system in your favor by enlisting the help of those who you’d otherwise contend with for jobs. No, you live by your own offerings – the union, you see, is a sinful aberration, a wreckage of the free market – which after all is certainly free enough to dispense with your job if not you – yourself should you prove to be somehow redundant. It’s not that markets aren’t efficient, you see, or that they are purely wicked or purely good, but it is a fact that wage competition is a losing game and that an employer knows that paying anything is paying too much – because in the marketplace the employer is likewise bound up in the death struggle of competition. All very sinister. All very banal.
Mechanization, electronic infrastructure and the steady progress of the machine world make you much less valuable than a machine, it’s only that you didn’t notice that it was happening. When you made car parts you didn’t notice and now a robot does what a dozen men once did. In the office you didn’t notice what was happening and now a computer does what a dozen men once did. In short order the higher functions of management and finance will be handed over to the more powerful minds carved into silicon channels by cleverer machines still. It’s not that the marketplace is wicked or that markets aren’t efficient, it’s that they just work better without you.
And yet, my political leadership tells me, cheerfully between choreographed missives regarding the state of Ohio State Football – that the solution to these matters is jobs. Jobs, will solve it all, nevermind that there are too many asses and not enough seats! Jobs will solve it, in the brief, fading interval in which jobs are things that could be had. Never you mind that the efficient market acts with a swiftness to obviate the need for jobs. Save for the few remaining instances where a man is called upon to do something less expensively than a machine might, for now, for this moment. Security is a luxury, and you can’t afford luxury, neither you nor the Bushman, you’ll be wolf-eaten and winter-struck, soon enough and the markets will operate efficiently – until the time arises where there are goods produced and no one to afford them, where there are services rendered and none to make use of them. But idleness, idleness is efficient, ask the Bushman – who doesn’t hunt when he’s not hungry, who doesn’t gather when he’s got no mouths to feed. Idleness is the most efficient of the various postures, the return on investment, calorically – is the best there is. Nevermind if it’s suicidal.
And yet, I’m told that jobs are the solution. Jobs. Eliminate all taxes on businesses that come to the state, to the city, compete, poorly, incompetently with the other states and nations and cities, give away everything and accept nothing in return! And do this, for the fulfillment of that most essential American commodity – the job.
It took me a minute. I’ll admit it, I’m clever but not usually smart, sometimes I get there though and I put it together. I was preparing my taxes you see, and I put it together. The politicians, who have some agency and thus, will never be put out of work by machines, have to calculate some source of income. They’ve agreed that no business should have to pay, lest it uproot itself and move far from their constituency, and they’ve determined that financiers needn’t trouble themselves with consequences, let alone contributions (to anything beyond political campaigns that is) and yet they’ve a need, to keep some, their most loyal voters (pesky things, always looking for handouts) at least fed, at least secure enough to show up in November – and so they offer a corrupt bargain – “I’ll try to make sure that you can have a job,” Says my imaginary politico, “And in exchange you can pay the various payroll taxes and income taxes that, when cobbled together from the massive and increasingly desperate population are somehow sufficient to pay for all of our various, collective misadventures” Jobs, are useful because it’s by jobs that wages are paid, but more to the point, it’s through them that taxes are gathered .
Here, I think of the Pyramids. A wonder of the world – mankind’s first, great monuments and which will be, most likely the last of the great works of mankind left standing. So why build your own mountains in a cemetery? It’s not a very obvious thing to do – to build a mountain in a cemetery in the desert. You don’t see a lot of people thinking that’s a good idea and there are a lot of very, very rich people out there now, who could, if they wanted to, have a mountain built in a cemetery in the desert. Likewise there’s enough hungry, wanting people, that there wouldn’t be a shortage of workers for the project. And yet you don’t see it. Now, reckless thinkers will go on and on about strange externalities, about uncanny superstitions and solemnly held beliefs – but you know people with solemnly held beliefs, and so do I, we all do- and they all have something interesting in common and that is – They Don’t Build Mountains In A Cemetery In The Desert. In fact, the only people who build crazy monuments without purpose are governments and their contractors and they do this, and we all know it (and it’s rather likely that the early agriculturalists of the 3rd Millennium before Christ likewise had this wisdom) because you have to give people something to do, or else they’ll figure out how to something for themselves and down that path – if you’re a politician, a ‘leader’ – lies unemployment. So find something for people to do, find a job for them, and then – sometime, early in the 20th century, you can figure out a way to profit from that, you can figure out a way to create an enormous regulatory bureaucracy staffed with sycophants if you are willing (and who isn’t) to slip a light yoke over every one of your constituents and tax their incomes, and link forevermore the fortunes of the state with the fortune of the state’s class of employers.
It’s ahistorical to call the builders of the Pyramids at Giza slaves, they weren’t. The writing that survives in those handmade mountains is all of the sort that appears still in lines of code and on bathroom stalls, graffiti extolling the virtues of the craftsmen involved – not slaves, not any more slaves than you are, or I am, but certainly – absolutely, bonded in servitude. Take some pride, do your work, fulfill the protestant sacraments and keep the wolves as far from the door as you’re able, and remember that there are rulers in this world whether elected by consent of the divinity and they care for you only so long as you retain some utility.
But I’ve been thinking more about work as a principle, a phenomenon.
Say you’re a bushman, you’ll work, sometimes. You’ll hunt and gather and endure strange privations and make unconscionable choices, you’ll be a bushman. You’ll exert effort. An observer could say that you are working - because it’s by the expense of calories in sweat and thought that you persist.
Say you’re a businessman, you’ll work. You’ll strategize and plan and though you’ll endure not too many privations, you’ll make unconscionable choices, you’ll be a businessman. You’ll exert effort. An observer couldn’t say exactly what you are working on – because it’s by the accumulation of unused calories that you are dying prematurely.
Say you’re a workingman, you’ll work. You’ll follow a pattern, obey regulations and you’ll endure strange privations, you’ll make no choices, you’ll be a workingman. You’ll exert an effort. An observer could say you were working because you pursued tasks singlemindedly for a scheduled interval and you were compensated in turn – and it’s by these accumulated hours that you’ll pay your rent.
Say you’re a thinking man, you’ll work. You’ll wonder why you have to work, exactly, you’ll be satisfied to get the steady work when it’s available, but you’ll think a bit, not obsessively mind, but still, you’ll think in your solitary moments about what it means that you’re working. You’ll think of the bushman and the businessman and the workingman – you’ll place yourself somewhere in a venn diagram that describes them all. You’ll be familiar with Marx, you’ll have some sense of your own value and consider why and how you parcel out the surplus. You might develop strange cares and exotic needs and thus you’ll work, though your heart’s not in it, your heart’s in thinking, you’re a thinking man and so you’ve a sense of Smith and how capital accumulates. You’ll look at your increasingly sophisticated computer and cleverer and cleverer tools and realize that it’s only a matter of time before you’re marked as an expense that can’t be justified by a businessman. You might have some nostalgia, misplaced or no, for the heyday of the workingman – having come from such people, you cast around and wonder where they’ve all gone. You’ll take the work you can get until you can’t and then you’ll have to catch as catch can and maybe go be the urban sphere’s version of a bushman. Maybe you’ll hunt opportunities, or suckers or victims, maybe you’ll gather cans or copper or unemployment. A shrewd observer can tell you’re working, you’re doing something and it’s somehow helping you to keep on living, it’s keeping you indoors anyway and heck – winter is coming. Winter is always coming and the wolves are always near the door.
It’s not that laziness is rewarded, it rarely is and idleness, whether a virtue or a vice, is its own reward – these aren’t the points to be made here, not the ideas this is meant to address. Put aside your suspicions about the people in the office next door and the good life that they may or may not be getting without working as hard or harder than you. Let’s think instead about working, but more to the point, about jobs.
Work, you do, like a machine – whether you get paid or not, it’s work just thinking, just sitting, just existing, there’s exertion. What I mean to speak about is the job. More to the point, I mean to speak about the weird serfdom that’s so commonplace as to be an assumption rather than a wonder. I follow my congressional delegation and local politicians through the various social media channels that they use to get their points across and their points are often, curiously focused on the matter of jobs. “Training! A local victory! A factory retained! Jobs kept!” There’s a lot of variation on this particular theme and I have learned something in my observance of politics and it is this: Whenever the parties that amount to the American leadership are in complete agreement on a matter – that matter is the rotten core that pollutes the otherwise good world. Save the financial system! (though most people might be net-debtors and beholden to it rather than served by it) – Conquer the fertile crescent! (though the expense in righteousness won’t be justified by the gains of the already morally suspect, though the results might be unconscionable and utterly ruinous, though such conquest might undermine the whole of society and tip us all into darkness) – Provide and sustain jobs! (though the tasks we set people to might be without merit and their spirits might be crushed by the weight of colossal misanthropy of the world of commerce). Really, it’s rather worth noticing when members of the different parties are in lockstep because this circumstance naturally indicates that their constituent members are being swindled the most thoroughly.
So Sherrod Brown and Mike Kasich and Rob Portman all tweet to me that they are attempting to retain or keep jobs – this in between their various anecdotal, almost human interactions with their environment, I am told about sports victories and classic car enthusiasm and wedged in between these hokey slices of almost plausible Americana is the tattletale insistence that jobs are the matter of utmost significance. Arbeit – it seems – Macht Frei.
Sure I was raised in an ostensibly protestant household and made to consider that famous ethic of work as a sacrosanct demonstration of True Character – punching the clock, showing up early, staying late, seeing it through till Friday and showing up, ready to work come Monday, the latter-day sacraments of a faith with precious few sacraments. Arbeit – I was raised to believe – Macht Heilig.
Which is an uncanny sort of nonsense. Work is fine, the Bushman works, the businessman works – everyone works, the ant and the grasshopper, each in their turn and season – but of these – which has a job. Sure, sure – it’s right and proper that idle hands be turned to useful labor and it’s right and proper that useful labor be compensated. Not fairly, mind, but according rather to the ebbs and flows of market forces, and cursed be he who seeks to unfairly tamper with that marketplace! No-no, you live and die by your competitive merits, and never, even ever, think to rig the system in your favor by enlisting the help of those who you’d otherwise contend with for jobs. No, you live by your own offerings – the union, you see, is a sinful aberration, a wreckage of the free market – which after all is certainly free enough to dispense with your job if not you – yourself should you prove to be somehow redundant. It’s not that markets aren’t efficient, you see, or that they are purely wicked or purely good, but it is a fact that wage competition is a losing game and that an employer knows that paying anything is paying too much – because in the marketplace the employer is likewise bound up in the death struggle of competition. All very sinister. All very banal.
Mechanization, electronic infrastructure and the steady progress of the machine world make you much less valuable than a machine, it’s only that you didn’t notice that it was happening. When you made car parts you didn’t notice and now a robot does what a dozen men once did. In the office you didn’t notice what was happening and now a computer does what a dozen men once did. In short order the higher functions of management and finance will be handed over to the more powerful minds carved into silicon channels by cleverer machines still. It’s not that the marketplace is wicked or that markets aren’t efficient, it’s that they just work better without you.
And yet, my political leadership tells me, cheerfully between choreographed missives regarding the state of Ohio State Football – that the solution to these matters is jobs. Jobs, will solve it all, nevermind that there are too many asses and not enough seats! Jobs will solve it, in the brief, fading interval in which jobs are things that could be had. Never you mind that the efficient market acts with a swiftness to obviate the need for jobs. Save for the few remaining instances where a man is called upon to do something less expensively than a machine might, for now, for this moment. Security is a luxury, and you can’t afford luxury, neither you nor the Bushman, you’ll be wolf-eaten and winter-struck, soon enough and the markets will operate efficiently – until the time arises where there are goods produced and no one to afford them, where there are services rendered and none to make use of them. But idleness, idleness is efficient, ask the Bushman – who doesn’t hunt when he’s not hungry, who doesn’t gather when he’s got no mouths to feed. Idleness is the most efficient of the various postures, the return on investment, calorically – is the best there is. Nevermind if it’s suicidal.
And yet, I’m told that jobs are the solution. Jobs. Eliminate all taxes on businesses that come to the state, to the city, compete, poorly, incompetently with the other states and nations and cities, give away everything and accept nothing in return! And do this, for the fulfillment of that most essential American commodity – the job.
It took me a minute. I’ll admit it, I’m clever but not usually smart, sometimes I get there though and I put it together. I was preparing my taxes you see, and I put it together. The politicians, who have some agency and thus, will never be put out of work by machines, have to calculate some source of income. They’ve agreed that no business should have to pay, lest it uproot itself and move far from their constituency, and they’ve determined that financiers needn’t trouble themselves with consequences, let alone contributions (to anything beyond political campaigns that is) and yet they’ve a need, to keep some, their most loyal voters (pesky things, always looking for handouts) at least fed, at least secure enough to show up in November – and so they offer a corrupt bargain – “I’ll try to make sure that you can have a job,” Says my imaginary politico, “And in exchange you can pay the various payroll taxes and income taxes that, when cobbled together from the massive and increasingly desperate population are somehow sufficient to pay for all of our various, collective misadventures” Jobs, are useful because it’s by jobs that wages are paid, but more to the point, it’s through them that taxes are gathered .
Here, I think of the Pyramids. A wonder of the world – mankind’s first, great monuments and which will be, most likely the last of the great works of mankind left standing. So why build your own mountains in a cemetery? It’s not a very obvious thing to do – to build a mountain in a cemetery in the desert. You don’t see a lot of people thinking that’s a good idea and there are a lot of very, very rich people out there now, who could, if they wanted to, have a mountain built in a cemetery in the desert. Likewise there’s enough hungry, wanting people, that there wouldn’t be a shortage of workers for the project. And yet you don’t see it. Now, reckless thinkers will go on and on about strange externalities, about uncanny superstitions and solemnly held beliefs – but you know people with solemnly held beliefs, and so do I, we all do- and they all have something interesting in common and that is – They Don’t Build Mountains In A Cemetery In The Desert. In fact, the only people who build crazy monuments without purpose are governments and their contractors and they do this, and we all know it (and it’s rather likely that the early agriculturalists of the 3rd Millennium before Christ likewise had this wisdom) because you have to give people something to do, or else they’ll figure out how to something for themselves and down that path – if you’re a politician, a ‘leader’ – lies unemployment. So find something for people to do, find a job for them, and then – sometime, early in the 20th century, you can figure out a way to profit from that, you can figure out a way to create an enormous regulatory bureaucracy staffed with sycophants if you are willing (and who isn’t) to slip a light yoke over every one of your constituents and tax their incomes, and link forevermore the fortunes of the state with the fortune of the state’s class of employers.
It’s ahistorical to call the builders of the Pyramids at Giza slaves, they weren’t. The writing that survives in those handmade mountains is all of the sort that appears still in lines of code and on bathroom stalls, graffiti extolling the virtues of the craftsmen involved – not slaves, not any more slaves than you are, or I am, but certainly – absolutely, bonded in servitude. Take some pride, do your work, fulfill the protestant sacraments and keep the wolves as far from the door as you’re able, and remember that there are rulers in this world whether elected by consent of the divinity and they care for you only so long as you retain some utility.